LineCast Networks
Back

Dinner Does Not Start When You Think It Does

LineCast Networks

Diners filling a sunlit terrace in a Spanish square in mid-afternoon, a public clock on the building behind

Diners filling a sunlit terrace in a Spanish square in mid-afternoon, a public clock on the building behind

On the longest day of the year, the sun stands directly over Vigo at twenty-three minutes to three in the afternoon.

Not sets. Not begins to slant. Reaches its highest point. The US Naval Observatory puts solar transit in Galicia at 14:37 around the June solstice, and in Madrid at 14:17. A Spaniard sitting down to lunch at half past two is not eating late. By the sun he is eating at a quarter past twelve in Madrid, and a few minutes short of noon in Vigo, and the clock on the wall is lying to him.

The lie is documented and it has a date. On 7 March 1940 the Spanish government issued an order advancing legal time by sixty minutes from the sixteenth of that month, "considering the convenience of the national timetable running in accordance with those of other European countries". Which European countries a Madrid ministry had in view in March 1940 the order does not trouble itself to say. Article five promised that the date for restoring normal time would be announced in due course. It never was. Spain has kept the borrowed hour ever since, which is how a country whose capital sits west of the Greenwich meridian ends up running its clocks with Warsaw.

Almost everything said about Mediterranean mealtimes is downstream of that order, and most of it is wrong in a way that is more useful than the received version.

The sun's version of dinner

Take the six countries whose eating hours are most often described as baffling and convert them out of clock time. These are Naval Observatory solar transit figures around the June solstice: Vigo 14:37, Madrid 14:17, Lisbon 13:38, Athens 13:27, Rome 13:12, Buenos Aires 12:55, Tokyo 11:43.

Now apply the offsets to the hour each place is reputed to keep. Half past nine in Madrid becomes 19:13 by the sun. Half past eight in Rome becomes 19:18. Seven in the evening in Tokyo becomes 19:17. Three cities separated by two and a half hours on the clock sit down to dinner within five minutes of one another once the sun is doing the timekeeping.

Athens comes out at 19:33, which is late but not remarkable. Lisbon, at eight on the clock, comes out at 18:22, the earliest of the six by a comfortable margin.

Then there is Buenos Aires, where half past nine on the clock is 20:35 by the sun. Argentina is the only one of the six whose reputation survives the arithmetic. Everyone else is not eating late. They are living on a clock that was set for reasons that had nothing to do with food.

A restaurant closed behind its shutter on an empty street in the afternoon, chairs stacked inside

The country that tried it and changed its mind

Portugal is the control experiment, and it is the reason the Iberian border is worth thinking about at dinner time.

A decree of 2 July 1992 moved the mainland onto Central European Time, in order to line up with the rest of the European Community and collect whatever economic and financial convenience followed. Nothing dramatic happened on the day it was signed. The clocks had gone forward on 29 March that year as usual, and the change was simply that they were not put back at the end of September; the Lisbon Observatory's register of legal time records the hour as having stayed on to the end of 1992. That is how the mainland arrived at Central European Time, by omission.

Four years later it went back. Decreto-Lei 17/96, of 8 March, sets out the reasoning in its own preamble, and the document is unusually candid for a piece of legislation. The change, it says, produced significant disturbance for citizens, who found themselves more than ninety minutes ahead of solar time in winter and around two hours thirty in summer. Children suffered in particular, with disrupted sleep and, in the decree's phrase, inevitable repercussions on rhythms of learning. Peak urban road traffic had been shifted into the hottest hours of the year. The hoped-for reduction in electricity consumption had not shown up. Given Portugal's geographical position, the government concluded, keeping Central European Time all year round was not advisable.

So at two in the morning on 27 October 1996 the mainland went back to coordinated universal time in winter and one hour ahead in summer, where it remains. Badajoz and Elvas are a short drive apart and an hour apart on the clock. Nothing about the light changes as you cross. The Portuguese side simply has its day arranged an hour closer to the sun, and eats accordingly.

A small Japanese counter restaurant busy in the early evening, dusk through the open doorway

What "closed" actually means

Greece is unusual among the six in writing the afternoon gap into a single national instrument. Police Regulation 3/1996, the codified text still in force, fixes hours of midday and night-time quiet: 15:00 to 17:30 and 23:00 to 07:00 from 1 April to 30 September, and 15:30 to 17:30 and 22:00 to 07:30 from 1 October to 31 March. Noisy work, loud music, shouting and boisterous dancing are all prohibited inside those windows. Elsewhere the equivalent rules are local. Italy's 1995 framework law on noise hands the job to individual comuni, which is why the protected afternoon in one town is not the protected afternoon in the next.

Be careful what you take from the Greek text, though, because it is easy to read it as more than it is. It governs noise, not trade. A Greek kitchen may lawfully cook and serve straight through the quiet window, and the offence on the page is the amplifier, not the grill. What the regulation actually tells you is something softer and more useful: the mid-afternoon here is protected enough that the state bothered to write it down, and a business that would rather not spend it shouting over a lunch rush has the whole weight of local habit behind closing.

Spain has no such statute for the gap, but it does have one for the edges. In the Madrid region, closing times are set by regional order rather than by the business: restaurants and self-service establishments are licensed from ten in the morning until two the following morning, cafés and bars from six in the morning until two. The licence is not the kitchen. A restaurant permitted to trade until two will usually have stopped cooking a long time before it, and that is the single most useful thing to grasp about Spanish dinner. It is late, it is a proper sitting rather than a rolling service, and it ends.

Italy runs the same two-service shape with the weight in the other half of the day. Istat's long-running survey of daily life found that in 2023, on weekdays, lunch was still the main meal for 63.3 per cent of Italians aged three and over, rising to 69.7 per cent in the south. That is down from 78.2 per cent in 1993, and over the same thirty years the share naming dinner as the main meal rose from 17.3 to 23.6 per cent. The gap is narrowing. It has not closed. A kitchen that takes lunch seriously will have shut the pass by mid-afternoon, and the evening service is commonly said to start earlier in Turin than it does in Naples.

Japan squeezes the day from the opposite end. Its standard time was fixed by an imperial ordinance promulgated on 13 July 1886 on the meridian of 135 degrees east, which crosses the country at Akashi, well west of the capital. Tokyo's solar noon therefore falls around 11:43, and Japan has kept no summer time since the occupation-era experiment was dropped. On the longest day of the year the sun sets over Tokyo at seven in the evening, and that is the best the year offers.

The other end of the Japanese evening is not shut by statute, whatever the arithmetic of a late arrival makes you hope. The Act on Control and Improvement of Amusement Business does impose a midnight-to-six trading ban, but article 13 aims it at the businesses the Act calls fūzoku eigyō: hostess and host clubs, bars kept under ten lux, venues with small screened-off seats, mahjong and pachinko parlours, game arcades. A restaurant is none of these. What the Act does to places that feed you is narrower and stranger. Article 33 requires a business intending to serve drink after midnight to file a notification with the prefectural public safety commission, and lets prefectures prohibit that trade outright in designated areas. Even that reaches fewer doors than it sounds, because the definition in article 2 carves out any business that, as its normal manner of trading, serves food recognised as an ordinary staple meal. Put rice or noodles on the menu and you are outside the category, which is precisely why the all-night ramen counter and the roadside family restaurant can pour beer at three in the morning and file nothing.

So the Japanese evening is bounded at one end by the sun and at the other by trade custom rather than by law, and custom is the stricter of the two. The last-order announcement is a genuine deadline, not an opening bid, and a room that still looks busy at eleven may have closed its kitchen well before it empties.

Argentina keeps its reputation. Law 26,350 of 2007 sets official time across the whole territory at three hours west of Greenwich in the winter period and two hours west in the summer one, leaving the executive to fix the summer dates each year. It has not fixed them since 2009. The naval hydrographic service's own register of adopted time zones shows the country at minus three, with no seasonal variation, from 15 March 2009 onward. Solar transit in Buenos Aires drifts across the year the way it does everywhere, about a quarter of an hour either side of 12:55, but the gap between the clock and the sun never jumps by a full hour twice a year the way it does in Madrid or Rome. Argentines are not the victims of a misaligned clock. They just eat late.

Eating on the wrong clock

The instinct on arrival is to search harder for a restaurant that stays open through the gap. Occasionally one does. The move that actually works is to change category rather than to keep hunting inside the same one.

The hours restaurants abandon are covered by different businesses with different licences. In Madrid a bar is permitted to open at six in the morning and a restaurant at ten, and that four-hour difference is not an accident of habit; it is written into the order. Bakeries, counters, delicatessens, grill windows and convenience stores exist in the seams, and in every one of these countries they are where the mid-afternoon and the very late evening are actually fed.

If your body wants lunch at half past twelve and Spain does not open its dining rooms until two, the sensible response is to take the offer the country does make. The menú del día repays understanding as an institution rather than as a bargain, because it began as a legal obligation. The Order of 17 March 1965 approving the tourist ordinance of restaurants made a menú turístico compulsory, at a price the tourism directorate would set and periodically revise, assembled from dishes already on the carte. An order of 19 June 1970 restructured the thing into the menú del día and the plato combinado del día.

It did not stay in that shape. An order of 29 June 1978 rewrote the chapter: the service was renamed the menú de la casa, restaurants classified at four and five forks were released from having to offer it at all, and the price fixed by the state became a ceiling of 80 per cent of what the same dishes cost on the carte. The obligation kept shrinking until Royal Decree 39/2010 repealed the 1965 ordinance outright, by which point, as that decree's own preamble concedes, the surviving state rules were merely supplementary to the regions' own. What survives in the dining room is the habit, which tells you how deep a midday institution can sink when the state spends decades insisting on it. It is a lunch. Looking for one at nine in the evening is looking for the wrong meal.

The mirror-image error is arriving in Japan and treating nine at night as early. It is not early there, it is nearly over. The pattern that works is to eat at the country's own peak and let the convenience store cover everything outside it, which it does, competently, at most hours.

For the first day, when your body is on one clock and the country on another, the crude rule that gets you into the right room is to ignore both and count from the sun: aim for dinner around seven hours after solar transit wherever you have landed. That puts you at 20:12 in Rome, 21:17 in Madrid in summer, 18:43 in Tokyo. Argentina will still be an hour and a half ahead of you, and that is Argentina's business.

Insisting on eating at your own hour is not discipline. It buys a dining room with no other customers in it, a kitchen doing you a favour, and a version of the place assembled for people who did not want to be there. The clock on the wall in Seville is a piece of 1940 foreign policy. The sun over the street outside is not.

Sources